The Eyeliner @cosme Ranked No. 1 for 2025: Heroine Make's Rich Keep, Explained

This post contains affiliate links. If you buy through them, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Our Disclosure page explains how affiliate links work on this blog.

An eyeliner that survives sweat, tears, sebum and rubbing all day — and then comes off with warm water. That combination sounds like a contradiction, and it is also, in the summary of @cosme's own reviewers, exactly why this one finished first. The product is ISEHAN's Prime Liquid Eyeliner Rich Keep, sold under the Kiss Me Heroine Make brand, and in @cosme's Best Cosmetics Awards 2025 it took first place in Best Eyeliner. This guide covers what it is, why it won, and what to check before buying it from outside Japan.

It is written for readers outside Japan choosing between listings that all say "Heroine Make eyeliner" — where the model and the shade, not the brand, decide whether they are buying the No. 1.

This is a research-based guide. We have not used the product; what follows is built from the maker's and retailers' published information and from @cosme's own award pages, which we read directly for this guide. We read @cosme's official 2025 Best Eyeliner page and the maker's published specifications, and checked the YesStyle listing shade by shade on November 8, 2026.

Heroine Make Prime Liquid Eyeliner Rich Keep at a glance: its No. 1 place in @cosme's 2025 Best Eyeliner ranking, the liner's specifications and Japan price, why @cosme's reviewers rated it first, the shade-list caution, and the YesStyle listing checked on November 8, 2026.


The record, from @cosme's own pages

@cosme is a Japanese beauty platform, and its Best Cosmetics Awards are decided from member reviews — the 2025 awards drew on 1,487,167 reviews. On @cosme's official page for the 2025 Best Eyeliner category, first place is the Prime Liquid Eyeliner Rich Keep, ahead of Dejavu's cream pencil eyeliner in second and CEZANNE's Ultra Fine Eyeliner EX in third. The maker, ISEHAN, announced three category wins at the same awards; this guide is about the eyeliner.

Two model names are worth fixing before anything else, because the brand's line-up invites confusion. Rich Keep is the model that won. The brand also sells a Smooth liquid eyeliner — a different, cheaper model — and a Rich Jewel variant, which is a different product again. In our own research for this guide, the English-language guides we found on Pinterest were about that Smooth model or about Japanese eyeliners in general; none was about Rich Keep. If a listing or a review just says "Heroine Make eyeliner", check which model it means.

What it is: a 0.1 mm brush pen, ¥1,320

The Rich Keep is a brush-pen liquid eyeliner, 0.4 mL, priced at ¥1,320 including tax in Japan — about US$8.33 at the exchange rate on November 8, 2026. Its specifications, as published by the maker, are built around durability: a firm brush tip of 0.1 mm; a liquid-control adjuster that regulates how much ink reaches the tip, so the line stays dense to the outer corner without skipping; and the maker's super-waterproof formula, resistant — in the maker's own description — to tears, sweat, sebum and rubbing. One qualifier belongs to that last phrase, and the maker prints it itself: "super" is the top tier within Heroine Make's own brush-pen liners, not the result of an independent test. Despite the formula, the liner is designed to come off with warm water rather than a dedicated remover.

Why it won, in @cosme's summary of its own reviews

@cosme publishes a summary of the member reviews behind the result, and the points it gives line up with the specifications above: the firm, ultra-fine brush is easy to draw with; many reviewers found it held up against sweat, tears and sebum, with lines that still looked freshly drawn at the end of the day; and the easy warm-water removal, despite that durability, is named as part of the appeal, along with the nuanced colour range and the vividness of the colour itself. That is the platform's summary of its members' reviews, reported here as such.

The honest catches, before the buying section

Three things to know before the prices below. First, the overseas price depends heavily on the shade: on YesStyle the standard shades run from US$8.54 to US$11.59 — roughly 1.0 to 1.4 times the converted Japanese price, a smaller markup than this blog usually finds — but 02 Brown Black costs US$16.44, about 2.0 times. Second, the shade lists do not match between Japan and overseas. YesStyle offers nine shade options, including limited-edition shades the maker's current Japanese range does not list, and one of those limited shades is already marked no longer available. Match the shade number and name on any listing against the shade you actually want; a wrong brown is the easy mistake here. Third, neither the durability nor the removal described above has been independently tested for this guide — the first is the maker's claim, the second is the maker's design, and @cosme's summary reports what its reviewers said. All three are labelled that way in this article because they are three different kinds of statement.

Buying it from outside Japan

Black Friday at YesStyle, until November 22, 2026

YesStyle's Black Friday sale runs until November 22, 2026, with up to 67% off selected brands. The coupon code WIN26 takes a further percentage off the product total: 8% on orders of US$79 or more, 10% on US$149 or more and 15% on US$199 or more. The code is for YesStyle members only, one coupon per order, and it ends on November 20, 2026 at 01:59 GMT.

The prices in the buying section below were checked on November 17, 2026, and no Black Friday price for this eyeliner had been confirmed at that point. Check the YesStyle listing for its current price before you pay.

YesStyle lists it as "ISEHAN - Kiss Me Heroine Make Prime Liquid Eyeliner Rich Keep" YesStyle – ISEHAN Kiss Me Heroine Make Prime Liquid Eyeliner Rich Keep product page. When we checked the listing on November 17, 2026, with the shipping destination set to the United States, it was rated 4.6 out of 5 across 194 reviews. The standard shades were in stock, priced by shade: 01 Jet Black and 07 Charcoal Black at US$9.76, 05 Mocha Greige at US$8.54, 06 Almond Brown at US$10.98, 03 Natural Brown at US$11.59 and 02 Brown Black at US$16.44; 04 Burgundy Brown was US$17.80 on a wait of about three weeks ("Awaiting Stock: 21 days"). A two-piece bundle set was also offered, priced by shade from US$15.37 to US$33.82. The standard shades are the straightforward buy; the shade-by-shade pricing is the part to read twice.

The second route is buying the Japanese retail product itself through a proxy-buying service such as ZenMarket (a candidate route for this blog, still being prepared), which orders from Japanese retailers at the Japanese price of ¥1,320 plus service and shipping charges. For most shades the YesStyle markup is small enough that the direct route is simpler; the proxy arithmetic becomes interesting for 02 Brown Black in particular, where the overseas price is the outlier.

Start with a black, and check the number

If you buy one first, make it 01 Jet Black or 07 Charcoal Black — both were US$9.76 and in stock at our check, and black is the shade where a 0.1 mm brush shows what it can do. If the shade you want is 02 Brown Black, look at the two prices before you pay: US$16.44 on YesStyle against ¥1,320 in Japan is the widest gap on the page, and it is exactly the case the proxy route exists for. And whichever shade you choose, do the thirty-second check from the catches section above: confirm the listing's shade number and name are the Rich Keep shade you meant to buy.

Japanese Makeup & Makeup Tools: A Buying Guide — this category's buying guide: how to choose among these products and buy them from outside Japan, with the shade and name checks in one place.

Related reading

The ¥550 Blush That Won @cosme's Best Blush Two Years Running — CEZANNE, whose fine eyeliner placed third in this category, is the brand behind this blush.

Two Drugstore Tools in @cosme's 2025 Overall Top 10: Rosy Rosa's Puff and Brush — two more winners from the same 2025 awards, from the overall list.

The cleansing oil that won @cosme's overall Grand Prize twice — the Grand Prize winner of the same awards.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

ReFa Heart Comb Aira (No. 1) and Heart Brush (No. 3) in LOFT COSME's 2025 Spring/Summer Sales Ranking: What's the Difference?

Bonbon Drop Stickers Explained: What They Are and How to Spot a Real Q-Lia Sheet